Skip to main content

Book 45: List of the Lost



Morrissey So-Famous-I-Only-Need-One-Name's first novel List of the Lost is nothing short of a tragedy. A tragedy for the publishers who agreed to stroke his inflated ego by allowing it to go to print, a tragedy for readers everywhere who waste precious hours (which seem to drag on) in the valiant effort to finish the novel (if you can call it that - it somehow seems an insult to all other novels to do so), and a tragedy for the plot, which should have been a moving and thought-provoking exploration of love and loss. List of the Lost follows a four-piece American relay team in the 1970s after they accidentally kill a homeless man. From thereon in, things get progressively weirder, as Morrissey struggles to decide if he is writing a fantasy, a philosophical novel or literary fiction. The entire thing is a mess.

A large part of the issue comes from Morrissey's self-indulgent writing style, similar to that of an angsty, precocious fifteen year old who has learned about literary techniques in school and cannot wait to show off what he has learnt. The text is littered with alliteration and assonance, and not in a good way - he often accomplishes this by making up words, which is highly problematic since he is neither Roald Dahl nor writing for children And when he is not making up words to accomplish this, the combination of words sounds so forced that it sticks in your mind for all the wrong reasons. Furthermore, List of the Lost is riddled with tangential sections, where Morrissey shares his 'philosophical' views on the world with his readers, reinforcing the self-absorbed 'teenage' vibe of the novel, which seems more like a reflection of Morrissey than a literary device. 

If all of this was not problematic enough, then there are the numerous errors, both in grammar and spelling, that cannot help but make you wonder (if you had not already) how this book was ever published? If it had been anyone apart from Morrissey List of the Lost would have been recycled after a first read by the most junior person in the publishing house. Frankly, it does a discredit to publishers - books should be published on their merit, not the author's fame. Admittedly, yes, there are moments when Morrissey, the lyricist, shines through, but it is only for a sentence and it is surrounded by so much nonsense that it loses a great deal of its magic. 

In short, do not read this book. Trust me on this one. 

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Book 31: Salut Galarneau!

Quebecker Jacques Godbout's 1967 novel Salut Galarneau!  is semi-autobiographical, produced as the diary of François Galarneau, a young Quebecker man who owns a hot dog stand but is striving to become a writer. Unfortunately, his father dies and his mother leaves for America, leaving him without any parental guidance, and his love life is a series of seemingly promisingly relationships that end badly. What follows is something of an existential crisis for François as he literally builds a wall around himself, debating the seeming incompatibility of living and writing. His solution is 'vécrire', a made-up verb which is a mix of the French verbs for to write (écrire) and to live (vivre), suggesting a hopeful and more positive future for François. The structure of the novel itself is rather bizarre, with no particular sense of chronology, as François recounts events from various points in his life in a sporadic manner, seemingly as they occur to him. Therefore, th...

Book 16: Before I Go To Sleep

S. J. Watson's thrilling debut Before I Go To Sleep  is gripping from beginning to end; written from the perspective of Christine Lucas, a middle-aged woman with a rare form of amnesia that prevents her from retaining new memories each night when she falls asleep. Therefore, when she wakes up each day, she believes that she is in her early twenties or younger, and has no recollection of the room she has awoken in or who the man lying next to her is. Each morning the man tells her that he is her husband, Ben, that they live together in London and that she had a serious accident which caused her amnesia. However, Christine is seeing Dr Nash, a specialist neurologist, without Ben's knowledge, and starts to keep a diary on his advice. Following on from this, it soon becomes clear that Ben is lying to her, and 'DON'T TRUST BEN' is underlined on the journal's first page, although Christine struggles to establish his motives. Keeping the diary not only helps Christi...

Book 14: The Story of Beautiful Girl

Put simply, The Story of Beautiful Girl  is absolutely beautiful. Inspired by the true story of 'John Doe no. 42', an intelligent deaf man who was institutionalised simply because he could not communicate,  The Story of Beautiful Girl , tells the story of Homan (John Doe no. 42) and Lynnie,  the eponymous Beautiful Girl who has severe developmental delays . The pair, who are very much in love, run away from the cruel and disgusting institution where they and their disabilities are hidden from public view. However, they are not just running away to escape from the horrors of the 'school' - Lynnie is heavily pregnant, but not with Homan's child, and cannot bear the thought of giving birth to her child in such a place. Fortunately, they find Martha, a retired and widowed schoolteacher who provides them with shelter and food. But their bliss does not last as officials catch up with them and Lynnie is taken back to the school, leaving Homan on the run and Martha a...